Where to Get the Best Key Lime Pies in Key West

Key West is known for many things — the breathtaking beaches, the funky fun of Duval Street, the historic Hemingway Home, and, of course, the best darn Key Lime pie you’ll find anywhere in the world! This is because this signature sweet and tangy treat originated here during the 1800s, and it’s been a staple ever since.

While you can get Key Lime pie pretty much everywhere in Key West, including at gas stations and convenience stores, some places do it better than others — and we know, we’ve tried them all!

So, when you’re ready to indulge in the island’s signature sweet treat, we’ve rounded up the eight best spots to grab a slice of Key Lime pie — just steps from your Key West vacation villa. Check out our guide to the best Key West beaches for more information on where to relax and enjoy the sun.

 

1. Key West Key Lime Pie Company 

• Address: 511 Greene Street, Key West


• Website: keylimepieco.com


• Price point: $$


• Best for: Award-winning Key Lime pie.

With tons of awards under their belt and several features on The Food Network, you know the pie at Key West Key Lime Pie Company is going to be good! In fact, many will argue it's the best Key Lime pie in the Florida Keys.

Enjoy a slice of their traditional Key Lime pie — made the old-fashioned way with a buttery graham cracker crust, sweet and tangy filling, and piled high with whipped cream. Of course, you’ll also find chocolate-dipped Key Lime pie bars to-go, another island staple, and Key Lime pie ice cream and milkshakes.

If you’re gluten-free, Key West Key Lime Pie Company has you covered with a one-of-a-kind “graham-less graham cracker crust.” We don’t know how they do it, but it’s just as delicious as their classic pies.

 

2. Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe

• Address: 200 Elizabeth Street & 33F Duval Street, Key West


• Website: keylimeshop.com


• Price point: $


• Best for: Drool-worthy chocolate-covered Key Lime pie bars.

A Key West staple for over 30 years, Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shoppe is a must-visit when on the island. And with two locations, you’re never far from a great slice of Key Lime pie.

While you’ll find an assortment of Key Lime-flavored everything, including pies, candies, sauces, and more — the #1 must-try item is Kermit’s signature chocolate Key Lime pie bars. Indulge in a slice of Key Lime pie on a stick, dipped in your choice of white, milk, or dark chocolate. It’s the perfect portable snack to grab while strolling Duval Street.

While you’re there, be sure to stock on some goodies to go. You can buy Kermit’s signature Key Lime barbeque sauce, perfect for grilling something up in your vacation rental. Or, snag a bottle of Kermit’s Key Lime juice to whip up your own pie when you get home — trust us, you’ll be glad you did!

 

3. Moondog Cafe

• Address: 823 Whitehead Street, Key West


• Website: moondogcafe.com


• Price point: $$


• Best for: Hip, artsy spot famous for burnt meringue Key Lime pie.

Serving up good food, good vibes, and a unique twist on the island’s most famous treat, Moondog Cafe is the place to be. Their Key Lime pie features a signature burnt meringue topping that’s caramelized for a sweet, crunchy texture.

While the Key Lime pie alone is certainly worthy of a visit, the food is equally delicious. Moondog serves up breakfast, lunch, and dinner with an island flair. You’ll find plenty of freshly baked pastries, sandwiches, salads, seafood, and gluten-free and vegan options. They even offer a vegan and gluten-free Key Lime pie tartlet made with coconut curd and a sugar-crusted shell.

Stop in for a bite, admire the colorful, quirky artwork, and enjoy some tasty Key Lime pie!

 

4. Key Lime Pie Bakery

• Address: 412 Greene Street, Key West


• Website: keylimepiebakery.com


• Price point: $


• Best for: A fun and funky spot for souvenirs and Key Lime pie.

Part bakery, party funky souvenir shop, Key Lime Pie Bakery is a must-stop for all things Key Lime-flavored and fun. Of course, you’ll find some fresh-baked, mouthwatering Key Lime pie here, but if you’re in the mood for some other tasty treats, too, this is definitely your spot.

Snag some Key Lime cake, candy, cookies, chocolates, and much more. Shop for funky souvenirs, bottled Key Lime sauces and dressings, baking mixes, and more. If it’s Key Lime, you’ll find it here, including body care products like Key Lime lotions, scrubs, and lip balm. It’s the perfect spot to grab a cup of coffee and a slice of pie and browse some one-of-a-kind goods.

 

5. Blue Heaven

• Address: 729 Thomas Street, Key West


• Website: blueheavenkw.com


• Price point: $$


• Best for: A breezy spot for island cuisine and meringue-style Key Lime pies.

One of Key West’s most famous restaurants, Blue Heaven is known for its laid-back vibes, roosters running around on the patio, and live music. But it is also renowned for its signature Key Lime pie.

Blue Heaven does Key Lime pie a little differently, it features a traditional sweet and tangy custard filling, but it's topped with a thick layer of fluffy meringue with a gorgeous golden crust. It’s a favorite among Key Lime pie connoisseurs.

While you can stop in just for dessert anytime, the regular menu at Blue Heaven is just as good as its pie. Dine in for breakfast, lunch, or dinner and enjoy island-style eats like Caribbean BBQ  shrimp and Jerk chicken, with Key Lime pie for dessert, of course!

 

6. The Cafe

• Address: 509 Southard Street, Key West


• Website: thecafekw.com


• Price point: $$


• Best for: Vegan Key Lime pie.

If you’re vegan, lactose-intolerant, have food allergies, or are just looking for a healthier version of Key Lime pie, The Cafe has you covered. You can indulge in this famous sweet treat, completely egg- and dairy-free — because everyone deserves good Key Lime pie!

The Cafe serves up plenty of plant-based dishes in a cozy, colorful spot just off Duval Street, so you can enjoy a meal or just stop in for a slice of their famous Key Lime pie or cheesecake. If you’re in the mood for a tangy refreshment, The Cafe’s signature Key Lime sangria is another must-try, made with fresh Key Lime juice and ginger, it pairs perfectly with the pie.

 

7. Old Town Bakery

• Address: 930 Eaton Street, Key West


• Website: oldtownbakerykeywest.com


• Price point: $


• Best for: A charming spot for coffee, breakfast, and Key Lime pie.

A small, family-run bakery in the historic district, Old Town Bakery serves up coffee, breakfast, pastries, and of course — some amazing Key Lime pie. While their homemade Key Lime pie with a gingersnap pie crust is surely enough to get you in the door, the thing locals and visitors alike love most about Old Town Bakery is the charm and hospitality.

Step into the cozy cafe, have a cup of Cuban coffee and a slice of pie while you chat with locals and learn about the history of the area.

In addition to great pie, you’ll find a whole case of other pastries and desserts to choose from, plus croissants, sandwiches, and more. There’s plenty to enjoy at Old Town Bakery and it’s one of the best coffee shops in Key West.

 

8. Mattheessen’s

• Address: 106 Duval Street, 419 Duval Street, & 614 Greene Street, Key West


• Website: mattskeywest.com


• Price point: $


• Best for: Key Lime pie, ice cream, and other treats. Sweet shop featuring fudge, ice cream, and homemade Key Lime pie.

With three locations on the island, you’re bound to run into Mattheessen’s at some point, and you’ll be glad you did when you try their Key Lime pie. While Mattheessen’s is best known for their homemade fudge and ice cream (which you can also get in Key Lime flavors), their Key Lime pie is a local favorite. It’s homemade, of course, with a sweet and tangy filling and a rich buttery graham cracker crust.

Just stepping inside Mattheessen's is a feast for the senses with the decadent scents of fudge and ice cream. While you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu, the Key Lime pie or Key Lime pie milkshake is definitely on the must-try list!

 

Grab a Slice of Paradise

From its dreamy landscapes to its tasty treats, Key West offers a slice of paradise in more ways than one. Don’t be afraid to order a whole pie or an extra slice to go, there’s nothing better than enjoying refreshing Key Lime pie by the pool in your vacation villa.

Ready to start your quest for the best Key Lime pie? Book your stay with Vacation Homes of Key West. You’ll find everything you need for the perfect vacation right in the heart of Key West. And most importantly, you’ll never be more than a few minutes away from great Key Lime pie!